Indio council delays vote on 1.8 million-square-foot warehouse project after marathon meeting
Nearly 20 residents testified during a meeting that stretched almost seven hours and past midnight before the council sent the Oasis at Indio proposal back for a smaller industrial footprint.

The Indio City Council voted early Thursday morning to continue its decision on the 183-acre Oasis at Indio project rather than approve or deny it, directing the developer to return with a reduced industrial component after almost an hour of public opposition to the plan’s 1.8 million square feet of light industrial space. The council did not set a date for the item’s return.
The vote came after a marathon session. The Oasis item did not reach the council until after 10:30 p.m., following other business earlier on the agenda. Nearly 20 residents waited more than five hours to speak, and the meeting did not adjourn until shortly after midnight.
What’s proposed
The proposed specific plan would replace the Gateway Specific Plan and Clinton Street Business Park Master Plan on land north of Interstate 10, south of Avenue 42, between the Thousand Palms Stormwater Channel and Monroe Street. At maximum buildout, it would allow up to 3,240 multifamily residential units, 20,000 square feet of commercial space and 1,806,290 square feet of light industrial use, according to the project’s staff report.
Trying to contexualize the size for the attendees, Mayor Elaine Holmes asked staff if there were any comparable projects in the city.
“None of that size, no,” City Manager Jonathan Nicks said. Nicks said the Buzzbox facility in north Indio is about 37,000 square feet, and if you combine all of the Mathis Home furniture store buildings, that accounts for about 250,000 square feet.
The project’s environmental impact report found the plan would generate significant and unavoidable impacts to air quality and greenhouse gas emissions that could not be reduced below regulatory thresholds, even with mitigation.
The Indio Planning Commission voted 3-2 in May to recommend the council deny the project, citing those unavoidable air quality and greenhouse gas impacts along with the scale of the proposed industrial component. The commission formalized that denial recommendation 5-0 in June.
Councilmembers press for answers
After the denial recommendation, the applicant, BH Properties, revised some parts of the plan. Changes included cutting the maximum industrial building height from up to 100 feet to 65 feet, increasing the freeway setback from 10 feet to 35 feet, raising the minimum landscaping requirement from 10% to 15%, and requiring larger, 36-inch box trees along Interstate 10. The revisions did not reduce the project’s 1.8 million square feet of industrial space or add environmental review, according to the staff report.
Councilmember Oscar Ortiz said that omission was central to his concerns. “After all these meetings, town halls, planning commission denial, we’re still at practically the same project,” he said, adding there had been “no significant change in warehouse space besides bringing it down in height.”
Ortiz also questioned figures the developer’s team presented that night showing an 88% reduction in air pollution compared with what current zoning would allow, saying the data had not been verified by the city.
Councilmember Glenn Miller raised similar doubts about the project’s financial case. “You’ve got 1,230 pages worth of items that we’ve had two days to really get a handle on,” Miller said, referring to new material submitted by the developer. “Some of the numbers just don’t add up.”
For example, developers said after accounting for up front fees, the city’s annual net income from the project would come out to $861,000.
“That is the positive revenue towards the general fund every year,” a representative for the developer said. “That’s ongoing, so when you multiply by that by years, it’s a significant amount.”
“$861,000, to me, is not a lot of money when you start talking about the impacts it might have,” Miller said.

The developer’s case
The developer’s team of at least six people spent much of the evening defending the project’s scale. Sean Matsler, a land use attorney representing the developer, compared Oasis to a nearly 200-acre industrial and retail project Matsler said he worked on in Eastvale.
“The parties would agree — and especially the city would agree — that this product has been an enormous success,” Matsler said, noting nearby home values have more than doubled since that project was entitled.
Bob Marra, CEO and publisher of Greater Palm Springs (GPS) Market Intel, argued Indio lacks the industrial space to keep jobs local. “Indio has the people, but you don’t have the jobs yet,” Marra said, pointing to the region’s 5.9% industrial vacancy rate. He said if the project isn’t built at the planned site at Oasis, the city will lose out on jobs.
However, members of the public took issue with that framing. “Are residents of Indio, our youth, only good enough for warehouse jobs?” Planning Commissioner Megan Scarborough-Eckel wondered during the public comment portion of the meeting.
The community responds
Public testimony ran overwhelmingly against the project, with recurring themes of air quality, traffic, city identity and distrust of the developer’s data.
Health and safety concerns featured prominently. One 11-year Sun City Shadow Hills resident drew comparisons between the planned project and the massive fire at the 500,000-square-foot cold-storage warehouse operated by Lineage Logistics in Boyle Heights back in June.
“If there is an accident, what will happen?”
Carly Steele, an attorney representing the nonprofit Supporters Alliance for Environmental Responsibility, argued the environmental review itself was inadequate, citing an outside ecologist’s findings on undisclosed impacts to wildlife and habitat, and urged the council to follow the Planning Commission’s recommendation.
Several speakers framed the project as a threat to Indio’s character. “You might as well change the brand of the City of Indio from the City of Festivals to the City of Warehouses,” Jerry Conrad, former board president of the Sun City Shadow Hills development, said.
“We’re not against the idea of development. We’re against the idea of warehouses. That’s all. End of story. Full stop,” Conrad said.
Not every councilmember was ready to abandon the project outright, even as they pushed for changes. Miller said he wasn’t “ready to throw the baby out with the bathwater,” but agreed with Ortiz that many of the developer’s figures needed to be independently verified before the council could act.
Ortiz was specific about what he wanted staff and the developer to bring back: a smaller industrial footprint, and a side-by-side comparison showing how the project’s impacts would compare to other developments of similar size already built in Indio, rather than only to the worst-case buildout allowed under current zoning.
“We’ve had the very worst-case scenarios,” Ortiz said. “Let’s compare it to other projects that we have around the city that are of similar size.” City Attorney Steven Pacifico told the council a significant reduction in industrial space would likely not require sending the project back to the Planning Commission, since it would represent a less intensive project than commissioners had already reviewed.
For many of the residents who stayed past midnight, though, the debate over acreage and setbacks missed a larger point.
“I have seen many developers like them that have done their damage come and gone, while those like myself who were born and raised here have dealt with those consequences,” Scarborough-Eckel said as she addressed the councilmembers in her public comment. “My generation can recall when terms like ‘ghetto’ and ‘dangerous’ were used to describe the city of Indio … I implore you to continue the good work that you’re doing and don’t fail the next generation of residents.”
